Kotomora
JLPT N1ConstructionWritten
Furigana

(よ)うとまいと(よ)うがまいがWhether or not; regardless of whether

This paired pattern presents an action and its nonoccurrence as two possibilities, then says that the following fact, decision, rule, or evaluation remains unchanged either way. It has a firm, rhetorical force similar to “whether or not” or “regardless of whether.”

What remains unchanged

The paired section sets up “the action happens” versus “the action does not happen.” The main clause then states something that holds under both possibilities. This is why the pattern works especially well with firm policies, fixed decisions, rules, evaluations, and facts that cannot be altered by someone’s choice.

Decisions and facts that hold either way

Notice that each main clause remains valid whether the first event occurs or not.

いんかいしょうにんしようとしょうにんしまいととうしゃはこの調ちょうけっこうひょうするほうしんだ。

Whether or not the committee approves, our company intends to publish these findings.

Analyze

だれしんじようがしんじまいがろくのこされたじつわらない。

Whether anyone believes it or not, the facts preserved in the record do not change.

Analyze

あめろうとるまいとしきてんていどおりおこなわれる。

Whether it rains or not, the ceremony will be held as scheduled.

Analyze

Choosing between the two linkers

and do the same essential job here: they connect the positive and negative possibilities and lead into an unchanged conclusion. Whichever one you choose, repeat it at the end of the pair.

Indifference, deliberation, and the everyday alternative

The target pattern says that the following result does not depend on the choice. By contrast, ようか~まいか means that someone is still weighing whether to act. For a neutral everyday statement of “whether or not,” ても~なくても is usually more natural; the target sounds firmer and more rhetorical.

かれようとまいとかいじゅうはじめる。

Whether he comes or not, we will start the meeting at ten.

Analyze

The meeting time is already fixed; the sentence is not asking which option he will choose.

More examples

ほんにんしゅっせきしようとしゅっせきしまいとしんていどおりはじまる。

Whether or not the person concerned attends, the deliberations will begin as scheduled.

Analyze

かれじつみとめようがみとめまいがしょうわらない。

Whether he admits the facts or not, the value of the evidence remains unchanged.

Analyze

せいようしようとようしまいととうろくりょうへんきんされない。

Whether or not you use the program, the registration fee is nonrefundable.

Analyze

けっようがまいがこんかいこころみにはがある。

Whether or not it produces results, this attempt has value.

Analyze

おうしゃえようとえまいとせんこうじゅんへんこうしない。

Whether or not the number of applicants increases, the selection criteria will not be changed.

Analyze

せいほうしんこうひょうしようがこうひょうしまいがじょうおくそくはしばらくつづくだろう。

Whether or not the government announces its policy, market speculation will probably continue for some time.

Analyze