ならともかくit would be one thing if
"It would be one thing if …": you name a case you could accept, then object to the real one. From a child, fine; but an adult?
From a child it would be one thing, but an adult making that kind of excuse is a problem.
Five minutes would be one thing, but I can't wait here for a whole hour.
How to form it
Noun/plain form + ならともかく
A な-adjective drops だ: 静かならともかく. Also のならともかく: 知らなかったのならともかく, "if you hadn't known, fine".
- Before it
- The case you could accept: a small amount (五分, 一度だけ), someone you would excuse (子ども, 初心者), a condition (安い).
- After it
- The real case and, usually, what is wrong with it: 困る, 無理だ, できない. A big amount often takes も: 一時間も.
- Tone
- Usually a complaint, a refusal or disbelief.
- Where you'll meet it
- Conversation, and opinion in writing.
In use
Once would be one thing, but making the same mistake again and again is a problem.
If it were what they wanted themselves, that would be one thing, but the people around them shouldn't decide their future for them.
An emergency would be another matter, but taking personal information off the premises in routine work is not allowed.
The first half isn't what happened
なら is "if it were": the first half is the case you would have let pass, not the one in front of you. In this one, nobody was joking.
As a joke it would be one thing, but to say that and mean it…
It can stop at なんて, with the disbelief left hanging.
Close neighbours
はともかくN2
Leaves one point aside to say what matters more. The point left aside is often a weak one.
Leaving the finer points of wording aside, the content is well organized.
ならまだしもN1
Nearly the same. The first case isn't good either, only easier to put up with.
Being late once I could put up with, but being late every week is a problem.
Check yourself
1Who came to the interview dressed like that?
学生ならともかく、
Choose an answer to see why.
2Which one fits?
見た
Choose an answer to see why.
More sentences
One night would be one thing, but I can't afford a whole week in a hotel.
A beginner would be one thing, but for someone with experience not to know this rule is a problem.
If it were quiet, fine, but I can't sleep in a room where you can hear music late into the night.