と思いきやjust when you'd think
You set up what anyone would have expected, then overturn it with what really happened: "you'd think so, but no". Mostly written, and often light or wry: the voice of a review, a blog or a sports report.
Just when we thought we had won, they turned the game around in the last minute.
with か
You would take it for an old system, but it was only brought in last year.
How to form it
Plain form + (か)と思いきや
A noun or な-adjective usually takes だ: コメディーだと思いきや. With か it goes straight on, and the guess is a little less sure: コメディーかと思いきや.
- Before it
- What you, or anyone, would have expected.
- After it
- What really happened, or what you found. Not a request, a plan or a guess.
- Tone
- A storyteller's twist, often amused. Usually too light for a formal report.
- In everyday talk
- と思ったら.
In use
You'd expect the new film to be a heavy social drama, but it turned out to be a breezy comedy.
I expected him to object, but he was the first to voice his support.
With the rain you'd have expected a small crowd, but the hall was so packed that people had to stand.
Something has already turned out differently
English "you'd think … but" can lead into advice. と思いきや can't: it tells how things turned out.
Not said: 簡単だと
(You'd think it was easy, but don't let your guard down.)
簡単そうに見えても、油断しないでください.
Close neighbours
Two things in quick succession, and the first really happened. Nobody was mistaken.
No sooner had the baby fallen asleep than it woke up again.
かと思ったN3
The everyday way to say you took something for one thing and it was another. Often かと思ったら again, this time with a real mistake.
I thought it was rain, but it was snow.
ところがN3
Opens a new sentence with the same turn, "but then…", in a plain voice.
There was heavy snow outside. But as it turned out, the shop was packed with customers.
Check yourself
1What happened?
彼女は
Choose an answer to see why.
2Which ending fits?
今日は
Choose an answer to see why.
More detail
きや is a fossil of classical Japanese, used nowhere else today. It is what gives the phrase its storytelling ring.
More sentences
A newcomer, so you'd expect a minor part, but the character turned out to hold the key to the story.
You'd have thought sales had fallen, but they were in fact well above the previous year's.
We expected it to be over quickly, but the investigation took a full six months.
You might expect a quiet exhibition, but it is one powerful sound-and-light display after another.