Kotomora
JLPT N3Construction
Furigana

かというとかといえばFraming a question and giving the answer

This pattern openly frames a question and then gives the speaker's answer, classification, or choice. It is especially useful when organizing an explanation or saying which of two descriptions is closer.

How the pattern works

The part before the pattern identifies the question to be answered: when, where, who, which option, or another category. The continuation must then resolve that question. The speaker is often not asking the listener for information; instead, the speaker raises the question rhetorically in order to foreground the answer.

Framing and answering the question

かいいつはじまるかというとぜんじゅうです。

As for when the meeting starts, it starts at ten in the morning.

Analyze

このまちいちばんしずかなしょどこかといえばかわ沿いのこうえんです。

If you ask where the quietest place in this town is, it is the park along the river.

Analyze

あたらしいかくだれまかせるかというとけいけんのあるとうさんです。

As for who we will put in charge of the new project, it will be the experienced Ms. Sato.

Analyze

Choosing the closer description

どちらかというと presents the following description as the closer fit, without claiming that it is perfectly or absolutely true. This makes it natural for preferences, personality, taste, and other answers that need qualification.

A qualified preference

A

あまものからものなら、どちらがきですか。

Between sweet and spicy food, which do you prefer?

Analyze
B

どちらかというとからもののほうがきです。

If anything, I prefer spicy food.

Analyze

The answer expresses a leaning rather than an absolute preference.

Answered question or unresolved question?

The target pattern announces a question and immediately supplies its answer. A simple embedded question followed by an expression such as “do not know” leaves the answer unresolved.

はっぴょうなんはじまるかというとです。

As for what time the presentation starts, it starts at two in the afternoon.

Analyze

The continuation answers the framed question.

はっぴょうなんはじまるかかりません。

I do not know what time the presentation starts.

Analyze

This is an unresolved embedded question, not the target question-to-answer pattern.

More examples

けっしょうせんいつおこなわれるかというとらいしゅうにちようです。

As for when the final will be held, it will be next Sunday.

Analyze

このいきゆきもっとおおいのはいつかといえばがつごろです。

If you ask when this area gets the most snow, it is around February.

Analyze

どのあんさいようするかというとようひくだいあんです。

As for which plan we will adopt, it will be the less expensive second plan.

Analyze

どちらかというとかれやくまわることがおおいです。

If anything, he tends to take the role of listener.

Analyze

このりょうどちらかといえばあまくちです。

This dish is more on the sweet side.

Analyze

りょこうなにっていくべきかというと、まずあまです。

As for what you should take on the trip, rain gear comes first.

Analyze
かというと・かといえば – Framing a question and giving the answer