Kotomora
JLPT N2Construction
Furigana

ないもの(だろう)かCould there be some way to...?

This construction earnestly or wistfully asks whether a difficult but desired action, improvement, or solution might somehow be possible.

A negative form expressing a positive hope

Although the verb before ものか is negative, the desired result is positive. The speaker is effectively asking, “Could we not somehow make this happen?” The question is usually reflective or rhetorical rather than a simple request for yes or no.

なんとかして、このいきそくかいしょうできないものだろうか

Isn't there some way we could address the shortage of doctors in this area?

Analyze

Literally: Could it not somehow be possible to resolve the shortage of doctors in this area?

The speaker wants the shortage resolved but does not yet have an easy solution.

When it sounds natural

Use this pattern for difficult improvements, prevention, assistance, cures, reforms, or hard-to-find solutions. It is less natural for an ordinary desire that the speaker can simply act on; the construction suggests an obstacle, uncertainty, or lack of direct control.

Personal and practical concerns

The hoped-for result should be clear from the context.

このふるしゃしんを、もといろちかじょうたいまでもどせないものか

I wonder if there is some way to restore this old photograph to something close to its original colors.

Analyze

だれか、ははかいについてそうだんってくれないものだろうか

I wonder if someone could help me think through my mother's care.

Analyze

Here the form works as an indirect appeal for assistance.

A search for possibility versus a direct wish

たいものだ directly voices a strong desire. By contrast, ないものだろうか presents the wish as a question about whether a difficult result or solution might be possible.

いつかほくおうをゆっくりたびしたいものだ

I would really like to travel slowly through Northern Europe someday.

Analyze

This is a direct wish, not a search for a solution.

Do not confuse it with strong rejection

When ものか follows an affirmative verb, it can forcefully reject the idea: “I would never...” In the wish pattern taught here, the verb itself is negative, and the speaker hopes that the corresponding positive result can be achieved.

そんなせきにんやくそくしんじるものか

As if I would believe such an irresponsible promise.

Analyze

This forcefully rejects the possibility of believing the promise; it does not express a wish.

More examples

ぢかざいりょうだけで、じょうじゅうたくつくれないものだろうか

Could there be some way to build durable homes using only locally available materials?

Analyze

なかなんめるくせなおせないものか

I wonder if there is some way to stop waking up repeatedly during the night.

Analyze

わかものあんしんしてそうだんできるまどぐちを、もっとやせないものだろうか

Couldn't we create more places where young people can comfortably seek advice?

Analyze

このそうおんすこしでもおさえられないものかと、じゅうみんたちはうったえた。

Residents appealed to the city to find some way to reduce the noise, even slightly.

Analyze

The construction can be followed by the quotation particle when reporting the concern or appeal.

いそがしいだけでも、たんじゅんぎょうどうできないものだろうか

Couldn't we automate the routine tasks, at least during busy periods?

Analyze

りょうしゃなっとくできるかいけつさくつけられないものか

Isn't there some way to find a solution acceptable to both sides?

Analyze
ないもの(だろう)か (naimono darou ka) – Could there be some way to...?